Black Stuff…

The previous owner coated the gable wall with a black substance, perhaps something like bitumen or tar, no doubt as weatherproofing.

Black stuff on gable wall
Black substance on gable wall
(Click on image to enlarge)

Since old buildings are meant to ‘breathe’, this ought to be removed.

Section of gable wall beneath (modern) chimney stack
Section of gable wall beneath modern chimney stack
(Click on image to enlarge)

This will require scaffolding: if the pointing is indeed to be raked out and redone, then clearly it would make sense to do both jobs together, along with any other work that requires scaffolding. …Such as removing those unsightly modern PVC barge-boards.

Modern chimney stack with modern PVC bargeboards
Modern chimney stack with modern PVC bargeboards
(Click on image to enlarge)

Pointing

The house has been re-pointed with cement mortar. This is unsuitable for old properties and will over time cause bricks to spall. Ideally, lime mortar should be used on period brickwork

Cement pointing on ground floor wall
Cement pointing on ground floor wall
(Click on image to enlarge)

However, removing (‘raking out’) cement mortar in order to re-point using lime may itself cause damage to the brickwork.

Contrast between pointing in lime (left) & cement (right)
Contrast between pointing in lime on left and in cement on right
(Click on image to enlarge)

…So my dilemma: to rake out and re-point or not?